How we test FM27 tactics
This page explains exactly how a tactic earns the Verified ✅ badge on FM Tactic Lab. We write the method down before testing so we can't move the goalposts after we see the results.
1. Same conditions for every tactic
- Game version: the FM27 release build. Every result shows the patch number it was tested on.
- One test save: the same database and the same start date for every tactic.
- Three squad levels: a title contender, a mid-table side and a relegation-threatened side from the same league. A tactic is verified per squad level, not in general.
- No mid-match tinkering: we only change things the game forces (injuries, red cards). Same team selection rules for every run.
2. How many matches
At least 20 competitive matches per squad level for a first verdict, and a full season (38 league matches) for a final verdict. Fewer matches than that and we say so clearly on the result.
3. What we record
| Metric | Why |
|---|---|
| Wins / draws / losses | The result you feel |
| Points per game | Easy to compare between tactics |
| Goals for / against | Attack and defence separately |
| xG for / against | Separates a good tactic from good luck |
| Date, patch, squad level, match count | So anyone can judge the sample |
4. The pass bar
Each tactic is compared with a baseline: the same squad playing the same matches with one of the game's own preset tactics. A tactic passes only if it beats the baseline on both points per game and xG difference. If it doesn't, it gets a Fail and we publish it anyway.
5. We publish failures too
Every tested tactic gets a public result: pass or fail, with the full numbers. Pro members get the tactic files that pass, one set per squad level, but the results themselves are public.
6. Re-tests after patches
Big patches change the match engine. After a major patch we re-test Verified tactics and update the badge and date. If a tactic stops passing, the badge comes off.
Limits we're honest about
- 20 to 38 matches is a small sample. Football Manager has a lot of randomness.
- One save can't cover every league or club. Your results can differ.
- We never claim a "guaranteed" or "100%" tactic.
Meanwhile: FM27 starter tactics (drafts) · Tactic Radar · Türkçe